Review Advice


There are TONS of incredible resources for writing rebuttals[1], and excellent critiques of the peer review system[2],[3], but there are far fewer guides for writing helpful reviews. I’ve collected the few that I’ve found here!

But what I always wanted was to see specific, concrete, actual examples of high quality reviews, which I was never able to find. Well, as I found out accidentally, it turns out that I myself am an award-winning review writer! To date, I have won 3 “special recognitions” for “outstanding reviews”. I’m working on anonymizing those to post them here soon!!

© 2022 / Molly Jane Nicholas / email